Different dogs have different training needs. That’s why no two dog training collars are the same.
Dog training in the good old days used to be a simple case of positive reinforcement – or harsh shock punishment. But that’s all changed. Dog training collars now come with a range of settings for different sensitivities. That’s why you need to know about the best dog training collar available.
“Why go to therapy when you can have a pet?” is a running joke my friends and I have. In honor of this joke, I’ve adopted a puppy annually for about three years.
I use the word puppy loosely because my merry mix of pooches includes a 10-year-old Jack Russell, an 18-month-old Poodle, and a 6-year-old German Shepherd. These breeds are known for their strong personalities, so I consider myself pretty knowledgeable on dog training by now.
In this review of the Best Dog Training Collar, you will find:
- Best overall training collar for dogs;
- Best training tool for large dogs and small dogs;
- Pros and cons of each collar;
- How we felt about the collars;
- And lots more!
We scoured the market to find the best ones, tested them all out, and set metrics for a fair rating.
Continue reading to find the perfect training collar for your companion.
Top 10 Best Dog Training Collars
Best Features Dog Training Collar
Mini Educator E-Collar Dog Collar Remote
The Mini Educator E-Collar Dog Collar Remote is great for dogs of all sizes. The different stimulation levels are a big plus for me. I wish they didn’t only include long prongs with the collar since I have a short-haired dog. Luckily it was easy to purchase them from the manufacturer.
- Many different types of stimulation
- Stimulation levels range between 1 and 100
- Emergency stimulation
- The handset is comfortable to hold
- Adjustable collar
- Stimulation probes are sold separately for short-haired dogs
- Small LCD. It may need more work from glasses-wearers to see
The Mini Educator E-Collar Dog Collar Remote might be better than one used by a professional trainer.
That’s right, better than a professional.
Most electronic dog training collars only have three training modes. This one has 100 stimulation levels. With this range of settings, you can find the best for your dog’s training.
The training modes on the Educator e-collar are:
- Regular stimulation
- Boosted stimulation
The collar is effective enough that most dogs will show progress with the tone and vibration training modes. This alone makes it this review’s Editor’s Choice.
The instruction manual makes it easy to operate this training system.
The transmitter is made of a rubberized plastic material. It’s waterproof and durable.
The collar is biothane plastic. It is easy to clean and doesn’t get a bad odor like other collars.
The light that comes with the collar is useful. I felt reassured to be able to see my dogs at night. Cars can see them too. The light is blocked by their long fur sometimes.
The other side of the tail…
You have to read the manual that comes with this training collar. It’s easy to switch to the wrong level of stimulation and hurt your dog, but only if you don’t know how to lock levels in. That’s why you should read your manual.
This Educator is priced on the higher end. However, it’s worth every penny. The features and ergonomic design prove why you spent the money with every use.
Related article: Best Dog Training Books
Best Budget Dog Training Collar
eXuby – Tiny Shock Collar for Small Dogs
The eXuby – Tiny Shock Collar for Small Dogs is great for small dogs. The collar receiver isn’t too big for small dogs and is comfortable to wear.
Be careful with the static stimulation. It can still be too strong for some dogs.
- Great fit for small dogs
- Easy to assemble
- Adjustable to fur length and thickness
- Adjustable stimulation settings
- Shock settings may be too strong for some dogs
- Not actually waterproof
Many dog collars don’t fit small dogs. The eXuby – Tiny Shock Collar for Small Dogs solves that problem. It is the perfect size for small dogs.
This collar was a breeze to put together. You don’t ‘really’ need to read the manual!
I like that short and long prongs were included. I preferred the longer prongs for my dog. You can choose which is best based on your dog’s coat.
The stimulation settings are adjustable. However, shock levels on this collar can be quite strong for small dogs. It is not recommended for very sensitive dogs.
Luckily, some dogs will behave just because they’re wearing the collar. No shock is needed.
This collar is more affordable, but it still does what you need. That’s why it’s this review’s Best Value Dog Training Collar.
Related article: What Are The 7 Basic Dog Commands?
Best Waterproof Dog Training Collar
I quite like the SportDOG 425X collar. It has a wide range of features and a long battery life.
- SportDOG has great customer service
- Great battery life
- Durable material
- The lowest shock setting can still be strong
- Can be ineffective on dogs with an undercoat
This is one of SportDOG’s most loved training collars in its range, thanks to its amazing battery life. That makes it our Top Pick for this list.
It’s rare to find an e-collar that doesn’t have several stimulation methods. This e-collar is no different.
This collar provides static shock, vibration, and sound stimulation. The vibration is strong enough to get your dog’s attention. The shock function is only needed to correct a strong negative behavior.
I found myself forgetting that the collar needed to be charged at all. A full charge lasted close to 70 hours. That translated to more than a month of training.
The beach is a trigger for my reactive dog, so we spent a lot of time training there. The collar excelled even in the saltwater of the ocean.
Your dog’s size plays a role when using this collar. It is recommended for larger dogs.
Related article: How To Prevent Your Dog From Chewing Their Dog Bed
Best Handheld Dog Training Collar
Garmin Alpha 100
If you need to train a large group of dogs, purchase the Garmin Alpha 100. You get quantity and quality.
- Fast connection to satellites for tracking
- LEDs help with visibility at night
- Dog icon shows what the dog is doing
- Battery lasts all-day
- The screen might be too small for some dog owners
- The remote is too quiet
You can train up to 20 dogs with the Garmin Alpha 100!
The 9-mile range meant I didn’t lose track of any dog that took off – they’re free to roam if you like. The training collar system loaded with GPS tracking helped with this too.
There are 18 levels of stimulation. I only used the lower levels – they’re enough to do the job.
Even though the touch screen is described as glove-friendly, I found it a bit challenging to use while wearing gloves. Just something to look out for is all.
The 20-hour battery life is amazing.
Best Durable Dog Training Collar
PetSafe Remote Training Collar
The PetSafe Remote Training Collar is easy to use and easy on the pocket. It has great range, and the battery lasts for a long time. I’d blind buy this any day of the week.
- Safety lock feature for high static shock levels
- Quick charge
- Tone and stimulation have separate buttons on remote control
- Long battery life
- Collar reacts immediately
- Buttons require some searching to find
- Some dogs may not react to shock levels
The shortest range of the PetSafe Remote Training Collar is 300 feet, and the longest range is 2700 feet. All dog owners can find the dog training collar that fits their needs. I preferred the longest range.
I instantly noticed a change in my dog’s behavior when using this collar. The beeping stimulation is often enough. The training process has been effortless with this collar.
Nothing is perfect. The charging port on this collar is prone to breaking. Dogs with more fur may not feel even the strongest shock.
Best Material Dog Training Collar
Garmin Sport PRO
The Garmin Sport PRO is a high-quality dog collar that meets every criterion for training hunting dogs. I especially like the light on it and the color bumper. This collar might not last forever, but it’s so good that you’ll always repurchase it.
- Variety of stimulation
- Bark limiter is a useful feature
- Great in all weather conditions
- Can train multiple dogs with one remote
- The collar starts to wear down after some time
- The remote range leaves something to be desired
The Garmin Sport PRO is suggested for training hunting dogs. It can withstand the weather conditions of hunting.
This remote dog training collar has four stimulation settings:
- Continuous stimulation
- Momentary stimulation
There are 10 stimulation levels on the shock feature. Dog owners can control them with a dial. The transmitter can be operated with one hand.
I could see my dog from 300 feet away, thanks to the light attached to this dog training collar. The remote control light can be switched on with a button.
What makes this different from other dog training collars?
The color bumper that’s made specifically for training hunting dogs. It teaches the working dogs to use their noses.
The higher stimulation levels on this collar are recommended for large dogs. I started training on the lower stimulation levels to determine my dog’s threshold.
As with all dog training collars, please read the instruction manual before you use it on your dog.
Best Dog Training Collar for Stubborn Dog
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS
The SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS delivers stronger stimulation for more stubborn dogs. It is waterproof and durable. Perfect for your wild four-legged friend.
- Strong stimulation
- Durable material
- Long battery life
- Stimulation can be too strong
- Controller is a bit small
SportDOG is a well-known brand for electric dog collars. They have a collar to fit any training need.
If your pup hasn’t responded to other training collars, they’ll respond to this one. It has 21 levels of stimulation.
The SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS is a collar you’d take to bootcamp with you. There’s a 500-yard range on this baby.
The collar is completely waterproof and can be submerged up to 25 feet without damage. I tested this feature the hard way when I accidentally dropped the collar into a lake during one training session. One fishing session later, and it was still good as new!
The battery life on this e-collar is impressive.
A full charge took us two hours. A full battery lasted us between 20 and 50 hours.
The collar is powered by rechargeable lithium batteries. So you’re not creating any extra waste.
If your pooch weighs less than 8 pounds, allow me to point you toward the eXuby Tiny Shock Collar. The SportDOG collar only caters to dogs above 8 pounds.
Best Battery Life Dog Training Collar
Petrainer Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
I recommend the Petrainer Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar if you can’t afford the Editor’s Choice, as it works almost the same without breaking the bank.
- Adjustable collar
- 100 levels of static stimulation
- The digital screen makes the reaction time of the trainer slower
- The remote goes into sleep mode while the training session is happening
The Petrainer Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar has 100 levels. That has only been seen in one other collar on this list.
I liked that I could adjust the collar size. This meant I could use it on different-sized dogs.
As someone who cares about the planet, the rechargeable remote and receiver are an added advantage.
The digital screen is a nice touch. But, I found that I was slower while using it. You have to look at the screen instead of just feeling for a button and pressing it.
Best Multi-Functional Dog Training Collar
WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training Collar
The WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training Collar is very safe for dogs. It doesn’t have a shock feature at all.
If your dog knows basic commands and only slips up now and again, this is the training collar for your buddy.
- Gentle correction
- The collar design fits against the dog’s neck well
- Easy to operate
- Will stop charging sometimes
- Not too effective on dogs with thick fur
Most remote training collars are shock collars.
Not the WOLFWILL Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training Collar, folks.
This is a good starter collar if your dog is used to positive reinforcement training. This collar is not for aggressive dogs.
It’s not a shock to the system.
There are 16 vibration settings. The vibrations vary in length. This feature is also different from other shock collars. You can choose the length of vibration based on the unwanted behavior you want to correct.
The fact that you can’t adjust the intensity of this collar might be a problem for timid dogs. If they find the vibration too strong, the training won’t work.
It’s too big to be used on smaller dogs.
The charging on this training collar is unpredictable. The battery life is pretty disappointing too. The device needs to be charged daily.
Best Adjustable Dog Training Collar
PetSafe Big Dog Remote Training Collar
The PetSafe Big Dog Remote Training Collar is perfect for big dogs. Even my Great Danes can wear it successfully and without any issue.
- Waterproof collar
- Long range
- Can fit big dogs
- Emergency static stimulation setting
- Multiple settings
- Lightweight collar
- The controller is a bit big
- It takes some effort to align batteries when replacing them
This is a standard training collar. The PetSafe Big Dog Remote Training Collar is suitable for indoor and outdoor remote dog training.
This model is specifically for large dogs over 40 pounds.
There are 16 settings. I found that static stimulation is perfect for correcting the particular behavior you don’t want. Industry-standard is waterproof, and this collar doesn’t fall short at all.
The collar is lightweight and not irritating to your dog’s skin. The battery life is a bit weak, and the collar will just not transmit commands sometimes.
Buying Guide To Selecting Best Dog Training Collar:
Dog training can save a dog’s life. So, selecting the right collar is important. There are a few key factors that contribute to the success of using the best dog training collar.
Value for Money
You want a dog training collar that will give you the biggest bang for your buck. Not only do you want a collar that is functional, but you need to be able to afford it.
How These Dog Training Collars Compare In The Value for Money Category
Ease of Use
A training collar that is easy to use will save you a lot of time! Remember, you want to be able to train your dog as efficiently as possible. So, having a collar that is easy to use is a must.
How These Dog Training Collars Compare In The Ease of Use Category
If features are important to you, then that will be a deciding factor in which collar you purchase. Different features include different types of stimulation, a range of stimulation levels, emergency stimulation, an additional handset, waterproof technology, an adjustable collar, and more!
How These Dog Training Collars Compare In The Features Category
You don’t want your training collar to die on you in the middle of a training session. It’s important to have a collar that you know will last for hours on end before it needs to be recharged.
How These Dog Training Collars Compare In The Battery Life Category
Size & Fit
The size and fit are crucial because you want your dog to be comfortable. Training a dog is hard enough, and they should be comfortable in order to learn.
How These Dog Training Collars Compare In The Size & Fit Category
Best Dog Training Collar FAQs
How do training collars work?
You press a button on the remote, and a signal is transmitted to the receiver on the collar. The collar emits a stimulus to correct your dog’s behavior.
Are training collars safe?
Training collars are safe when you follow their instruction manual. Please don’t leave them on your dog for long periods of time.
Do dog trainers recommend shock collars?
Some dog trainers recommend shock collar training. However, they emphasize the importance of using the collars safely and correctly.
Conclusion: Best Dog Training Collar
We’ve just gone through the best of the best dog training collars out there.
Did you find the one for you and your dog?
If you’re still unsure…
Our favorite is the Editor’s Choice Educator E-Collar Humane Dog Training Collar. The 100 stimulation levels are something we can’t get over.
A close second is the Top Pick. This collar’s long battery life proves why it’s so popular.
If you’re working on a budget…
The Best Value collar is for all the small pups out there. Its pocket-friendly price puts it a cut above the rest.
May your dog training endeavors be successful!
Amazon Best Rated Products - Last Updated on 2023-12-07. DISCLAIMER: Some or all of the product links on this page are affiliate links. The operator of this website received a small commission if you purchase products through these links, HOWEVER, there is no added cost to you. These commissions help to fund the operation of this FurryFriendsGear.com